A performance review, sometimes called a performance appraisal or employee evaluation, is a structured conversation between a manager and employee about the employee’s performance, progress, and future goals.
It’s one of the most important tools in people management, offering a chance to reflect on results, discuss strengths and areas for improvement, and plan for what comes next.
At its best, a performance review gives clarity and direction. It helps employees understand how their work contributes to the bigger picture, gives employees the opportunity to grow, and allows managers to recognise effort, address challenges, and support development.
When done thoughtfully, it becomes less about evaluation and more about progress, helping people feel valued, aligned, and motivated to do their best work.
Why Performance Reviews Matter
Performance reviews exist to build accountability and connection. They help people understand what’s expected, recognise what’s gone well, and agree on what comes next.
For human resources teams, they play a practical role. Reviews provide a written record of performance, goals, and conversations. This is all important documentation that supports promotions, pay changes, or, if necessary, performance management. It’s a foundation of compliance and fairness.
For employees, reviews provide structure and space. A well-run review meeting is a productive conversation, not a surprise. It’s where feedback becomes actionable and progress visible. When managers use examples from real work, it helps employees see their impact and understand how to build on it.
Performance reviews also shape culture. They’re proof that feedback is valued and that success is noticed. When human resources teams encourage regular, thoughtful reviews, it helps to build employee engagement, encourage growth, and create a culture of continuous improvement. Over time, those moments of reflection lead to real, lasting growth and development.
Types of Performance Reviews
There’s no single way to conduct performance reviews. The right structure depends on the size of your team, the kind of work you do, and what you want to achieve.
Annual Performance Review
An annual performance review is the most traditional format: a formal checkpoint that summarises progress over the past year. It often connects to pay or promotions.
A good annual review looks back at the goals set during the last review, discusses what worked, and revisits long-term goals. It’s a record of work performance, but also a guide for what comes next.
Quarterly or Biannual Reviews
Many companies hold more frequent reviews to stay aligned. Quarterly reviews help track progress, adjust priorities, and keep momentum high. They make it easier to notice small wins and course-correct early.
Continuous Feedback
Instead of relying on one formal review, some teams choose a flow of regular check-ins. These ongoing discussions create a culture of continuous feedback. By the time the upcoming performance review arrives, nothing should be a surprise.
360-Degree Appraisal
A 360-degree appraisal gathers feedback from peers, reports, and managers to give a fuller picture of performance. It helps managers assess how well someone collaborates, leads, or contributes to wider goals.
Self-Evaluation
A self-evaluation helps employees reflect on their performance, think about their strengths and areas of improvement, and share where they want to achieve more. When combined with manager feedback, it turns reviews into real two-way conversations.
How to Conduct an Effective Performance Review
An effective performance review isn’t about judging. It’s about understanding. It gives both sides clarity and confidence. Here’s how to do it well:
1. Prepare for the Performance Review
Before meeting, take time to gather context. This should be past goals, recent results, or specific examples of both success and challenge. This ensures a fair, balanced conversation.
Employees should prepare for the performance review as well, noting achievements, blockers, and anything they’d like to discuss. Preparation keeps the discussion meaningful.
2. Make it a Two-Way Conversation
A review should feel like a dialogue, not a verdict. A two-way conversation invites openness and makes for much more productive outcomes. Encourage employees to share how they think things are going, what’s worked, and what they’ve learned. The more candid and honest you can make it, the better.
That exchange builds trust, and that's where the real improvements begin.
3. Provide Constructive Feedback
The supervisor’s role is to deliver feedback that’s both honest and actionable. The best reviews focus on specific actions, not assumptions.
For example:
“You’ve managed tight deadlines effectively this quarter, but quality checks slipped in two projects. Let’s find a process that helps maintain both speed and accuracy.”
Constructive feedback helps employees see the path forward without defensiveness.
4. Recognise Strengths and Weaknesses
Always start with what’s working. Recognising employee strengths and weaknesses shouldn't feel like listing out a bunch of criticisms. It’s about balance. Praise good performance with specific examples, then explore how those strengths can support other areas.
5. Set Goals and Development Plans
A strong review ends with forward motion. Set goals that are clear, meaningful, and measurable. Include a development plan or action plan that lists resources, support, and timelines.
Goals should connect to career development and the company’s vision. The best ones are actionable and realistic, steps that employees can take and managers can support.
6. Follow Up
The conversation shouldn’t end once the meeting does. Regular follow-ups help employees make progress and keep motivation high. The review is a snapshot; what happens next drives change.
Performance Review Examples (By Category)
Examples help turn theory into something real. The best performance review examples use clear, relatable language and keep feedback tied to outcomes. They give managers confidence and employees direction.
1. Recognising Good Performance
-
“You consistently deliver high-quality work ahead of schedule. Your attention to detail has improved the job quality of the entire team.”
-
“Your proactive communication keeps everyone aligned and helps us avoid last-minute surprises.”
-
“You’ve stepped up as a mentor to new hires, setting the tone for how we collaborate.”
These examples highlight good performance while showing its effect on others.
2. Encouraging Growth and Development
-
“You’ve shown great initiative in identifying problems early. Let’s work on documenting your solutions so the rest of the team can learn from them.”
-
“Your workload management is strong, but prioritisation under pressure can improve. We’ll explore a few strategies in your next development plan.”
-
“You’ve deepened your technical knowledge — now let’s focus on communication and influencing skills.”
Balanced feedback like this helps employees need to improve without discouragement.
3. Communication and Collaboration
-
“You share updates regularly and flag risks early — that transparency makes collaboration smoother.”
-
“You work well across teams, but looping others in earlier could prevent delays.”
-
“Your calm and clear communication helps others stay grounded under pressure.”
Performance reviews provide a chance to acknowledge how communication impacts overall work performance.
4. Leadership and Initiative
-
“You’ve taken ownership of key projects and guided others through complex challenges — a clear sign of a high-performing contributor.”
-
“You’re quick to spot inefficiencies and propose solutions. Next quarter, let’s identify one process to improve across departments.”
-
“Your constructive feedback to peers has raised team standards and built trust.”
Strong examples of leadership recognise influence, not just output.
5. Meeting Objectives
-
“You met all your Q3 goals, improving conversion by 12%. Let’s look at automation to build on that success.”
-
“Most of your targets were met, though the documentation rollout missed its deadline. We’ll adjust timelines in your next action plan.”
-
“You’ve shown dedication to long-term strategy — a strong example of successful performance.”
These are outcome-focused, fair, and based on evidence.
6. Addressing Challenges Constructively
-
“You’ve missed a few deadlines recently. Let’s review what’s behind that and agree on steps to fix it.”
-
“Quality issues have surfaced in recent reports — we’ll pinpoint the cause and build a clear, actionable plan.”
-
“Client feedback suggests communication could be clearer. Let’s align on expectations and templates that help.”
This approach keeps feedback objective and supportive — focused on outcomes rather than blame.
7. Reviews Across Global Teams
-
“You’ve adapted brilliantly to working across time zones and have become a bridge between regions.”
-
“Written updates sometimes lose nuance across languages; we’ll create shared templates to help.”
-
“Your cultural awareness has helped onboard new colleagues more smoothly.”
These examples reflect the nuances of managing a distributed, international team.
8. Self-Evaluation Examples
Encourage employees to write their own self-evaluation before the review meeting. It builds confidence and ownership.
-
“I’ve streamlined onboarding for new hires but want to work on presentation skills.”
-
“I’m meeting deadlines consistently and would like to take on more strategic projects.”
-
“I’ve mentored new colleagues and delivered major projects — my next goal is to strengthen leadership skills.”
Self-reflection turns reviews into genuine two-way conversations.
9. Closing the Review
-
“Let’s agree on three actionable priorities for next quarter.”
-
“We’ll meet monthly to track progress and adjust as needed.”
-
“You’ve made strong improvements since last cycle; let’s build on that with new meaningful goals.”
Every review should end with clarity — and a plan.
What to Include in a Performance Review Template
A fair process starts with structure. A clear template keeps reviews consistent and unbiased, especially for global teams.
Include:
-
Employee details and role
-
Objectives and outcomes
-
Strengths and achievements
-
Strengths and areas of improvement
-
Development goals and action plan
-
Comments from both sides
-
Sign-off for record-keeping
This structure ensures every performance review stays focused, balanced, and legally sound.
How Often Should You Conduct Performance Reviews?
There’s no universal rule. Many companies still rely on an annual performance review, but high-performing organisations often add regular check-ins throughout the year.
Frequent conversations allow managers to use to evaluate performance in real time and help employees understand expectations.
Research shows employees who receive meaningful feedback regularly are several times more likely to stay engaged at work and improve productivity.
Performance Reviews in Global Teams
When your workforce spans countries, reviews require cultural and legal sensitivity.
Different norms shape how feedback is given and received. A team member’s response in Tokyo might differ from one in Dublin, and both can be right.
Consistent templates, clear expectations, and localised guidance help ensure fairness. Using performance management software lets HR and managers document goals, monitor progress, and stay compliant, wherever people work.
Boundless helps companies conduct performance reviews that meet both cultural expectations and legal obligations, ensuring fairness everywhere you operate.
Performance Review vs. Performance Management
Performance management is the full journey; goal-setting, coaching, feedback, and recognition.
A formal performance review is one milestone along that path.
A review may summarise progress, identify what’s working, and reset focus for the next stage. Together, they create the framework for lasting growth, accountability, and alignment.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Even experienced HR leaders can fall into traps. Avoid these:
-
Vague feedback — always give actionable examples.
-
One-way dialogue — make it a conversation, not a speech.
-
Neglecting follow-up — build an action plan and revisit it.
-
Ignoring strengths — recognise what’s working before what isn’t.
The most effective performance reviews are calm, consistent, and fair. These are the kind that allow managers to lead better and allows employees to grow confidently.
The Boundless View
At Boundless, we believe that great employee performance reviews should result in both the employee and the employer feeling more aligned then they were before. They need to be consistent, clear, and calm. The kind that leave everyone informed, not anxious.
They’re a chance to listen, to align, and to plan. Done well, they focus on specific results, provide constructive feedback, and build mutual respect between managers and employees.
That’s what successful performance management looks like. Not dramatic, not rushed, just done right.
FAQs
What is the purpose of a performance review?
A performance review gives structure to how a manager and employee talk about work. This includes what’s gone well, what could be better, and where to focus next. It’s used to assess how well goals have been met, recognise effort, and agree on clear next steps.
Done properly, it also supports fair pay and promotion decisions, ensures transparency, and keeps human resources teams compliant with local employment laws.
How often should companies hold performance reviews?
The ideal frequency depends on company size, structure, and culture.
-
Annual performance reviews are still the norm in many organisations and work well when supported by regular check-ins throughout the year.
-
Quarterly or mid-year reviews allow managers to adjust goals sooner and spot challenges earlier.
-
Continuous feedback cultures rely on short, informal conversations that make the formal review easier.
What matters most is consistency — employees should always know when to expect feedback and how their progress will be measured.
How should employees prepare for their performance review?
Employees should take time to reflect on their performance since the last review.
This includes:
-
Listing key achievements and specific examples that demonstrate impact
-
Reviewing any goals set during the last review
-
Thinking honestly about growth areas and what support might help
-
Preparing questions for the manager about development or upcoming priorities
Coming prepared turns the review into a two-way conversation rather than a one-sided evaluation.
4. How can managers prepare for a performance review meeting?
Preparation shows respect. Managers should gather data on results, feedback from colleagues, and examples of good performance and challenges.
They should also:
-
Review the employee’s action plan or development plan
-
Note progress toward long-term goals
-
Prepare constructive feedback that’s actionable and balanced
-
Schedule enough time for a genuine discussion, not a rushed chat between meetings
The goal is to provide constructive feedback, recognise success, and leave the employee with a clear path forward.
5. What should be discussed during the review meeting?
A well-run review meeting covers:
-
Achievements – where the employee delivered strong results or showed initiative
-
Challenges – where more support or clarity is needed
-
Feedback – both from the manager and from the employee
-
Goals – updating or setting new targets for the next period
-
Support – resources, training, or mentoring that will help
A review should always end with actionable next steps and agreement on follow-up check-ins.
